As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

REVIEW: The Manny – Romeo Preminger

The Manny - Romeo Preminger

Title: The Manny

Series: Guilty Pleasures Book 2

Author: Romeo Preminger

Genre: Romance

LGBTQ+ Category: MM Gay

Publisher: Self

Reviewer: Cristofer, Paranormal Romance Guild

Get It On Amazon

About The Book

Gabe’s life changed in a heartbeat when his husband died in a plane crash, leaving him a widower and a single dad to their newborn daughter. Two years later, he’s finally ready to return to his work as an artist. When a bright, attractive college grad named Matthew presents himself as a live-in caretaker for Isabela, Gabe thinks he’s the perfect fit.

Matthew is more than the solution to Gabe’s childcare problems. The two men soon fall into bed together, and Gabe wonders if Matthew was heaven-sent to create the insta-family of his dreams. But behind Matthew’s irresistible exterior lurks a desperate soul who could plunge Gabe into the greatest nightmare of his life.

The Review

Just let me preface this review by stating that I’m not usually a reader of dark fiction, and it’s been a while since I’ve been disturbed by what I’ve read. The Manny is very dark and twisted at times, and while this didn’t impact my assessment of its quality or ability to keep me engaged, it was a shadow that followed me all throughout the book. 

The book opens with Gabe looking for a babysitter, someone to watch and care for his daughter, Isabela. Fortunately for Gabe-or so he thinks-the search is over when he meets Matthew, a charming, attractive young man. Gabe is still reeling from his husband’s death, and when Matthew comes along, Gabe is immediately attracted to him. They hit it off.

At first Gabe considers this to be an ethical concern, given that Matthew is ten years younger than him, responsible for taking care of his daughter, and because he’s paying him. As things progress, however, it becomes apparent to people around Gabe that Matthew has developed strong feelings for him. Gabe shrugs this off until Matthew initiates a kiss with him one night, and Matthew tells him how attracted he is to Gabe. Gabe is flattered, but tells Matthew he’d like to take things slow. Matthew seems put off by this at first, but gives Gabe the space he needs. 

It should be noted that Gabe is a tortured artist type, someone who is tender and kind, thoughtful, etc., whereas Matthew is a “feral, country boy.” The two couldn’t be more different, but you know what they say about opposites attracting…

One night, Gabe and Matthew engage in their first sexual encounter, but Gabe asks Matthew if he’d be okay with taking things slow (again). Matthew becomes upset with Gabe, and this creates tension between the two of them. A little while later, Gabe begins to gradually see the cracks in Matthew’s mask–how hot-tempered he is, how jealous he gets, how violent and volatile he can be. 

Matthew soon becomes linked to all of these disappearances, but Gabe is so smitten with Matthew that he can’t see him for what he really is. Despite the many signs…

Matthew is deceptive and cruel, manipulative and calculating, petty and maniacal, in every sense. I never felt sorry for him. This is rare for me as an empath, but I kept hoping something would happen to Matthew, some kind of retribution, but the nightmare only ended once Matthew got away.

If you enjoy twists and turns, and rooting for the dark horse, give The Manny a try.

The Reviewer

Cristofer Garton is an avid romance reader and LGBTQ activist hailing from the hills of Appalachia. He currently resides in Kentucky with his husband, son, and four cats. When Cristofer isn’t reading or writing reviews, you can find him planning his next ghost hunt or buying smelly candles.

The Paranormal Romance Guild was established in 2009 by 8 Indie Authors and one Reviewer to be a constant help for authors. You can be a free author member, submitting your work for review OR become a Premium Author Member for a small yearly fee and enjoy many extra services including Free Beta Reads, Author Giveaways and many others. Your reviews are posted on our 3 FB Sites, Amazon, Goodreads, Twitter and Instagram. WE REVIEW ALL GENRES LGBTQ+ welcome.

Check out our website:


Leave a Comment